Monday, August 22, 2011

The Hunger at the End of the World

by Sophie

HUNGER

Juliet and I occasionally do a workshop titled "Creating Emotional Depth," where we guide writers to identify and describe and heighten the emotions their characters experience. During one of the first times we taught that workshop, I had a sudden epiphany. It might have been because we were sitting in a room full of women with a table laden with donuts in the back, but I blurted out that if a writer was stuck on exploring a female character, she should consider her relationship with food.

In that split second that followed my declaration, I had a flash of regret, because it was most assuredly a moment of projection. I have a complex relationship with food. I pour all my emotions into afternoon binges during tough times; I greet the deepest hurts of my life with rare, but debilitating, bouts of not eating at all. I sense emotion in my gut, and satiety often gets confused - at the synapse level, where I can't do anything about it - with response to fear, to sadness, to loss.

But that does not mean that every woman experiences the same. Or does it?

Certainly, in that room, there was a lot of nodding and hell-yeahs. I've read a fair bit about disordered eating and I'm not naive about how wide-spread it is. We had a good discussion of the subject, and when it was tabled, it was with the knowledge that there was far, far more to say and explore.

Which, of course, I naturally do in fiction.

When I began the AFTERTIME series, Cass's relationship with food was central to her character. (In fact, I think I blogged about it here). Cass practiced asceticism, punishingly so, in a variety of ways; also, the apocalypse delivered a whole new set of food challenges. I saw metaphors in physical denial and hunger; a spectrum of lush vitality to starvation that was being played out on both the global and individual canvases.

But now that all three books have been turned in, I see that I let this subject languish. I did not plumb or pursue it; hunger became a mere by-product of events, something experienced more or less equivalently by everyone, and in simple terms. Food sources were wiped out; a "replacement" nutrition source - adequate but pleasureless - appeared. Sustenance replaced enjoyment. Satiety was not possible; overeating too. The occasional treat (a can of fruit, a cup of coffee) was welcome but not fantasized about, at least on the page. I was aware of sweeping the whole subject aside to pursue other sensory aspects.

Both LOST and WALKING DEAD "fail" in this way as well, surprisingly. I didn't watch either with great care, but from what I remember, in each, the subject is glossed over. Food is scarce, and there are scenes of gathering and preparing (berries and boars and such) but truly it's ludicrous to think that what was shown the audience was even a fraction of the effort or emotional space such a problem would consume. Those people had to be *hungry* - achingly, soul-bruisingly so - but that is not revealed on the screen.

(The treatment of Hurley's character doesn't even bear considering in this realm. I found it objectionable and unrealistic.)

Research with prisoners of war reveals that, in deprivation, people fantasize about food above and beyond anything else - more so than sex, than escape, than any other missed pleasure. This remains a challenge for me to explore in the future.

9 comments:

Rachael Herron said...

Am loving REBIRTH, and even if you don't dwell on hunger, the need is there. I'd picked up on it. And I think the idea to think about hunger/food relationship for your character is golden. Gonna go do that....

A. J. Larrieu said...

I love this idea...food is such a sensual thing, and so personal. How a character engages with food can say so much about her. (I'm remembering a scene in a Bad Day For Pretty where Chrissy gives Stella a kind of pancake sandwich on her way out the door...it was so vivid, I can still see it, and it was an opportunity to show a lot about both characters.) And I love to have my characters cook things, especially for each other.

Juliet Blackwell said...

You didn't say anything about potato chips...that hunger is as real as it gets ;-)
Seriously, as usual you've put your finger on a really important theme here, how deep the hunger goes for all of us. Great stuff to mine for understanding ourselves, and our characters.

Shizuka said...

This is such an interesting post. A lifetime ago, at least that's how it feels, I traveled for six weeks in Africa for work. Mostly, we talked about food, fantasizing about certain types of noodles and fish and familiar junk food. And we weren't really hungry -- we just missed our lives and food was the most visceral part of home.

Shizuka said...

This is such an interesting post. A lifetime ago, at least that's how it feels, I traveled for six weeks in Africa for work. Mostly, we talked about food, fantasizing about certain types of noodles and fish and familiar junk food. And we weren't really hungry -- we just missed our lives and food was the most visceral part of home.

Lisa Hughey said...

I think in the Aftertime series with Cass that survival and finding/protecting her daughter is so much more paramount than food.

For some people, oddly, food is a non-issue. Certainly not for me!! This post made me realize I did this! The opening scene of Betrayals has Staci in prison where she's shoveling in mush with dirty fingers and remembering spice rubbed steak and white table cloths.

Mysti said...

The weirdest thing about hunger I've discovered on this 1,000 calorie a day diet (medically supervised meal replacement, don't worry! I'm safe & healthy!), is that my body can grow disinterested in food. It's easy to say no to stuff that I couldn't resist before. After a week I dreamed about food, but the dream was about the most delicious granola bar ever created, not a doughnut or steak like I'd expected. weird, no?

I am hungry most of the time, but it's a physical hunger that's very easy to tolerate. Of course, the emotions that my eating masked are all bubbling up and demanding attention, but really, that's a good thing. I believe there's conservation of feelings--they wait for you, no matter how long it takes...

When I return to the world of normal food again, it'll be much harder to ignore my hunger, they say. A delicious metaphor, that food feeds hunger as well as satiety...

Nicole Peeler said...

You are awesome. I'm thinking so many thoughts right now about food and how we take it for granted in fiction. We never show meals (or bathroom breaks) because they're just THERE, right? But what if they aren't?

Jeorge Mackay said...

To finalise, Sunday payday loans are a best suggested financial aid which shows lender’s consciousness for their borrowers. Such kind of loans shows lender’s positive attitude towards borrowers and their needs in every situation and know more about our services please visit us saturday payday loan lenders.

http://sundaypaydayloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
http://12monthloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
http://weekendpaydayloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/
http://weeklypaydayloans.directlendersuk.co.uk/